Is Your Child Struggling in Reading? There’s a Reason Why
“If we are to obtain results never before achieved, we must expect to employ methods never before attempted.” (Francis Bacon, b 1561 d 1626)
============
In the mid-1970’s, after three years of intensive and exhilarating work, I was finally almost finished with a Ph.D. in reading education. I was eager to finish my dissertation and get started with a career of helping struggling readers. I never dreamed my first client would be my own son, and that helping him would be a major fork in the road for me.
My younger son eagerly started first grade. With his sunny, outgoing personality, dimpled grin, advanced linguistic skills, and wide experiential background, we were anticipating smooth sailing. However, it soon became apparent that he was lagging in reading—he was not catching on. My first reaction when I heard the news was shock and awe; my second reaction was: “He’s a lucky little guy to have me for a mom.” Because a great deal of my course work in the Ph.D. program was focused on helping struggling readers, I assumed I could work diligently with him, applying what I had learned, and he would soon be back on track. That’s not what happened.
I did work diligently with my son, as did his very competent first grade teacher, and he was most cooperative, willingly doing everything he was asked—but nothing helped. Perhaps inevitably, the school asked me to attend a “What are we going to do about your son?” meeting. The team that had assembled recommended that he be tested to see if he had a learning disability and, if so, he would be transferred to the elementary school across town so he could attend the special program for learning disabled students.
When I asked what would happen to him instructionally, I was invited to observe the special program. I spent a full day at the school, and what I saw was competent professionals working hard with struggling students, doing the same things I and his first grade teacher had been doing for months—things that weren’t working! I would have shipped my son to the moon if I thought he could get help there, but I wouldn’t ship him across town—away from his friends and a teacher he loved—to get help that I knew couldn’t possibly work. When I respectfully declined the program, I was asked to sign a waiver saying that because I had refused the special program, the school district was no longer responsible for my son’s reading. I signed the waiver, and in so doing, I sent a strong message to myself: I alone in the world was responsible for my son’s reading, I had a Ph.D. in reading, and I didn’t have a clue what to do to help him.
I knew nothing was wrong with my son, or me, or his teacher, or his family, or his culture (areas reading professionals point to when confronted with the mystery of children who don’t read well), so it must be the methodology. Could it be that we simply weren’t teaching reading right?
I eventually came up with two questions that I thought if I could answer—or at least shed light upon—I might discover how reading might be more effectively taught. The questions: How does the brain learn a process? (Reading is a process—a “how-to” thing.) and, What is it that brains do when they read well?
I stepped outside the field of reading (been there done that—no answers there!) and began doing library research in fields of inquiry that I thought might shed light on these questions. I studied information theory, communication theory, linguistics, language acquisition theory, cognitive psychology, neuropsychology, and neurobiology—always synthesizing what I was learning and applying it to my two questions. Eventually, as I had hoped, ideas did pop out of my head about how to teach reading in a different way. My ideas constituted a paradigm shift in the field.
The research took three years, and by then my son was in third grade for the second time, emotionally damaged due to the failure in school because he couldn’t read well enough to do the required work. I started working with him using my new ideas and hoping to see an incremental improvement in his reading ability. What I saw instead was totally unexpected—a complete elimination of his reading problem in just three months!
The result confirmed the validity of both the research I had done and the application of the theoretical constructs to a coherent instructional methodology. What made the amazing result possible? (The result has been verified by replication over a 30-year period of time, by third party, gold-standard research, and by literally hundreds of program evaluations using gain scores as measured by pre- and post- standardized reading tests.) The answer lies in what my research revealed all those years ago.
When an individual learns to read, he builds a network in his brain to guide the doing of it. Reading problems are caused when the network is not built correctly: because the network has errors encoded in, it operates inappropriately when it is accessed to read. The individual has to read the way the network is guiding the process; he cannot read in any other way. It follows that the only way to eliminate a reading problem is to compel the brain to re-model the network so it yields excellent reading every time it is accessed to make reading happen. Brains are “plastic,” but they are unlikely to accidently encounter an environment that would cause them to remodel existing circuitry. The tutoring environment must be precise to facilitate the remodeling work and ensure it will happen.
The major challenge to getting the brain to remodel erroneously-operating circuitry is this: process learning operates (and is learned) primarily implicitly—below the level of conscious awareness, so processes (like reading) cannot be explicitly taught. Rather, an environment must be constructed that will compel the brain to figure out all of the implicit aspects of the process and to meld them seamlessly with the explicit aspects.
An easy example is bicycle riding: when an individual rides a bicycle, he is totally aware he is riding it, but he has no idea what his brain is doing to make it happen. No parent tries to explain to a child the proper muscle movement required to ride a bike. Parents know intuitively that the child’s brain must figure it out for itself and that the parents’ job is to simply provide the environment and give feedback based on performance when they can. If the parent constructs the proper environment, the child—in almost all cases—will figure out how to ride the bike.
The same is true of reading: because the process operates primarily implicitly, reading can’t be explicitly taught. Rather, an appropriate environment must be constructed so the brain can figure out for itself the implicit aspects of performing the complex cognitive act of reading.
The reading field has never acknowledged or recognized the implicit nature of procedural learning. The advice of reading professionals? Systematic and explicit teaching of basic skills, focused on word identification for initial instruction and for anyone struggling with reading. Reading professionals have assumed that the foundational skill for reading is word identification for 150 years. But is it? Neuroscience would suggest otherwise.
The evidence from neuroscience that supports the idea that word identification is not the foundational skill of reading comes from two directions. First, short term memory has a very limited capacity; it can process only an average of seven bits of information at one time. For the individual who is trying to read by decoding (or sounding-out) every letter, if a word has more than seven letters, the task becomes difficult if not impossible. If the individual recognizes every word as a sight word, then comprehension of sentences containing more than seven words becomes problematic. Second, fMRI scans done as subjects read word lists show very different neural activation patterns than those done as subjects read sentences and paragraphs—indicating that word identification is not the same cognitive act as reading connected text.
If the foundation and main event of reading is not word identification, what is it? This exercise will help to answer that question:
With hocked gems financing him
Our hero bravely defied all scornful laughter
That tried to prevent his scheme
Your eyes deceive he had said
An egg not a table correctly typifies this unexplored planet
Now three sturdy sisters sought proof
Forcing along sometimes through calm vastness
Yet more often over turbulent peaks and valleys
Days become weeks
As many doubters spread fearful rumors about the edge
At last from somewhere welcome winged creatures appeared
Signifying momentous success
J. Dooling and R. Lachman, 1972, “Effects of Comprehension on Retention of Prose”
Journal of Experimental Psychology, Volume 88, pages 216-222.
Most people who read this do not comprehend it even though they can read every word, and the individual phrases make some sense. But now, consider this: Christopher Columbus. Read the selection again.
Telling you ‘Christopher Columbus’ points to the place in your brain where you have stored what you know about him. This enables you to anticipate the meaning of the passage, which is the foundational skill for reading. Technically speaking, to read excellently, the brain must create anticipatory sets relative to the author’s intended meaning. The brain must figure out how to plan, coordinate, and integrate numerous complex neural systems so such anticipation is possible. Phonics is necessary to read, but the brain doesn’t use phonetic information to figure out what the words are. It strategically samples such information as required to help anticipate the meaning. Once the anticipation is created, if the brain is uncertain about its validity, it uses phonics to make sure the anticipated meaning is the same as the author’s intended meaning.
For everyone who struggles with reading, the reason is because their brains have built an erroneously-operating neural network to guide the process. Why did they build it wrong? Because they were taught by well-meaning parents and teachers that in order to be successful readers, they had to learn how to quickly identify each and every word on the page. In reality, what excellent readers do is anticipate the meaning.
To eliminate a reading problem, the brain must be in an environment that compels it to remodel neural circuitry so it successfully guides the complex process of anticipating the author’s meaning. The methodology I first implemented with my son all those years ago, now called Read Right, provides such an environment. You can access the program for your child via live, real time on-line tutoring. Visit www.tutoringforreading.com to learn more.♦
Recent Posts
- Typesy Typing Curriculum
- ABC Read Phonics-Based Program for Adults and Children
- Greek ‘n’ Stuff . . . Latin, Too – Buy Books Online
- Signing Online
- Number DNA Online Software by Neaton Mathematics
Archives
- February 2021
- January 2021
- December 2020
- November 2020
- October 2020
- June 2020
- March 2020
- September 2019
- January 2019
- July 2018
- June 2018
- May 2018
- March 2018
- February 2018
- January 2018
- December 2017
- November 2017
- October 2017
- August 2017
- July 2017
- June 2017
- May 2017
- April 2017
- March 2017
- February 2017
- January 2017
- June 2016
- April 2016
- January 2016
- November 2015
- May 2015
- January 2015
- November 2014
- August 2014
Categories
- 'Cello lessons
- 'Cello players
- #David Skaggs
- #SumBlox
- 14 Rooms
- 1775 Rebellion board game
- 1900s New York
- 85255
- A.C.T. Prep
- Abeka
- Academy Games
- Accredited Online High School
- ACT prep
- ACT score improvement
- Acting as learning
- Acting resources
- addition
- Addition & Subtraction
- ADHD
- Adult Reading
- Advanced Math
- Affordable Homeschool Resources
- Alberti Veil
- Alene Harris
- Algebra
- Algebra
- Aliyah
- alternative church
- Alternative Education
- Amanda J. Murray
- American Academy
- American Christianity
- American families
- American Geography
- American History
- American History
- American Sign Language
- Americans
- Ancestry
- AP Biology
- AP Chemistry
- Apologia
- Aquanaut
- Archeology
- Art
- Art Curriculum
- Arts
- Astronaut
- Audio Learning
- Auditory Learners
- autism aids
- Autism reading
- Bard of Avon
- Basket weaving kits
- Beacon College
- Beginning Reading
- Beginning Reading
- Bessie Bress
- Bible Education
- Bible memory builder
- Bible Study Resources
- Bible-based Education
- Biology
- Biology Kits
- BJU Press
- Board game creative writing
- Board games
- Board Games
- Board games that teach
- Boston
- Botanical Drawing Academy
- Botanical Illustration
- Brain Development
- Brian Wasko
- British History
- Bullying resources
- by Emerson Sandow
- by Joseph Grayhaim
- by Michael Leppert
- C ollege Prep
- C.S. Lewis
- Calculus
- Character Building
- Chemistry
- Chemistry at home
- chemistry books
- Chemistry for Everyone
- Chemistry Kits
- chemistry review
- children's books
- Chinese
- Chinese
- Christ
- Christian Biblical
- Christian books
- Christian College
- Christian curriculum
- Christian curriculum software
- Christian Education
- Christian homeschooling
- Christian literature
- Christian math curriculum
- Christian penmanship
- Christian reading curriculum
- Christian Students Science
- Christian teaching software
- Christopher Marlowe
- Church at Home
- Church of God
- Classic Literature
- Classroom writing projects
- Cleo Cat
- CODiE Award
- College
- College Counselor
- College for Disabled Students
- College Prep
- College Reading Aids
- College-Prep Music Course
- Computer Reading Tools
- Computer Skills
- Computer Tools
- Computer-based games
- computer-based math programs
- Confidence building
- Continental Army
- Cool Tools Math
- Crafts at home
- Create Press
- Create-a-Story
- Creation Science
- creative composition
- Creative Writing
- Creative Writing
- Creative Writing Programs
- Critical Thinking
- Crystal Reed
- Cultural Geography
- Culture
- Curriculum
- Dabble board game
- Dabble board game review
- Daily Grams
- Daily Math Review
- Dianne Knesek
- Dick Parman
- Digital books
- division
- Downloadable Books
- Downloadable Greek
- Dr. Aditya Nagrath
- Dr. Alvaro Arias
- Dr. Ed Myers
- Dr. Suzanne Lahl
- Drawing & Painting
- Drawing curriculum
- Dyslexia
- Dyslexia
- Early literacy
- early reading
- Early Spanish reading
- Earth Science
- Earth Science Kits
- Easy Grammar review
- Eco-friendly
- Ed Myers
- Ed. D.
- educational board games
- Educational games
- Educational toys
- Edward DeVore
- Elementary acting
- elementary creative writing
- Elementary Math
- Elementary math
- elementary math
- Elementary math program
- elementary math resources
- Elementary reading
- elementary science
- Elementary theatre
- Elephant Learning
- Emerson Sandow
- English
- English History
- English Language Learners
- English usage
- English vocabulary
- English writing
- European countries
- European History
- Evelyn Fannin
- Family
- family activity
- family board games
- Family church
- family creative writing game
- Family education
- Family Fun
- Family Game Night
- Family Heritage
- Family History
- Family learning
- Family projects
- family reading
- Farming Board Game
- Fiction writing
- Fine Art
- followers of Jesus Christ
- Foreign Language
- Foreign Language fiction
- Fred Coulter
- Free
- Free Bible resources
- Free Bible study resources
- Free Greek Resources
- Free Home Education Resources
- Free Homeschool Resources
- Free Resources
- Free Sample
- Free Sample Lessons
- Free Student Resources
- Free Teacher Resources
- French
- French
- Full Curriculum
- Games
- Geography
- Geometry
- George Barna
- German
- German
- Globe
- Grammar
- Grammar resource
- Greek and Latin study aids
- Greek Practice Materials
- Greek study aids
- Greek word roots
- Green Learning
- hand-eye coordination
- Handwriting
- Handwriting
- HAP products
- Hawaii
- Hebrew
- Hebrew Reading
- High school chemistry
- High school creative writing
- High School Diploma
- High School English
- High School Graduation
- High School Math
- high school online
- High School Reading
- High School Reading Aids
- High School Science Kits
- High School Writing
- Highlighting
- History
- Home Bible study
- Home church
- Home education math
- home education math products
- Home Education resources
- home school family
- home school math
- home school math products
- Home school music aids
- home school programs
- Home-school
- Homeschool
- Homeschool Art Program
- homeschool creative writing resources
- Homeschool English program
- Homeschool family
- Homeschool Grammar
- Homeschool Greek
- Homeschool History Resource
- homeschool math
- homeschool math material
- Homeschool Music accessories
- Homeschool Music aids
- homeschool programs
- Homeschool reading
- Homeschool Resources
- Homeschool Travel
- Homeschooler
- Homeschoolers
- Homeschooling
- Homeschooling and College
- Homeschooling English program
- Homeschooling Family History
- homeschooling history
- Homeschooling math
- house churches
- Hugg-a-Planet
- Human Anatomy
- Hygiene
- IL
- Illinois
- Immigrants
- Immigration
- improve SAT scores
- interactive online books
- Israel
- Italian
- Italian
- Jacques Cousteau
- Japanese
- Jennifer Nairne
- Jennifer Nairne review
- Jennifer Swanson author
- Jennifer Swanson books
- Jesus is our mediator
- Jewish life
- Julia Duin
- K-8 math curriculum
- Kathleen Cotter
- Kathryn Sullivan
- Kindergarten
- Kindergarten Spanish
- King Arthur
- Landmark College
- Language Arts
- Language Arts
- Latin word roots
- Learning Styles
- Lexington and Concord
- Life Science Kits
- Linda Silbert
- Literacy
- Logos Science
- Ltd.
- Lucy Geringer
- M.Ed.
- Manipulatives
- Maps
- Marine Biology
- Marvin Reynolds
- Math
- math basic
- Math basics
- math concepts
- Math Essentials
- Math games
- math help
- Math K-8
- Math Online
- math program review by Emerson Sandow
- math program review by Michael Leppert
- Math Software
- math solutions
- Math Subscription Service
- Math Supplements
- math teacher
- Math teacher resources
- math teaching
- math teaching aids
- math turors
- Math videos
- Mathematics
- Matthew Blackwood
- Maureen Mortlock
- mega-churches
- Memorization
- Memory Mark™ tool
- Memory Training
- Mexican storybook
- Michael Leppert
- Michael Leppert review
- Middle School creative writing
- Middle School Math
- Middle School Reading
- Middle School Reading Aids
- Middle School Science Kits
- Mini church
- Minute Men
- MjL
- Montessori math
- Morningside Center
- Mountain Math
- Movement
- multiplication
- Multiply & Divide
- Music Education
- Music History
- Music Instruction
- Music Planners
- Music Practice Aids
- Music Practice Materials
- Music teaching aids
- Music Teaching Materials
- Music Theory Online
- musical learning
- Musical Theatre curriculum
- Nancy D. Nelson
- NASA
- Nashville
- National Homeschool
- NEEMO
- Neurolinguistics
- new kind of Christian
- New Rochelle
- New York
- No Drama College Counseling
- Numbers Revolution
- ocean exploration
- OM Braida
- On-line programs
- Online books
- Online Education and Independent Study Programs
- Online high school
- Online high school math
- Online High School Music Theory
- Online homeschooling
- Online learning
- Online Math Advanced
- Online math ages 2-12
- Online Math Games
- Online Music Theory
- Online Program
- Online Reading
- Online Spelling
- Online Teachers Manual
- Online writing
- Online writing curriculum
- organized religion
- Orton-Gillingham
- Parent Teacher Resources
- Parents guidance
- Parts of Speech
- Peace Toys
- Peacetoys
- Pen and Ink
- Periodic Table
- Ph.D.
- phonemes
- Phonemic awareness
- Phonics
- Physical Geography
- Physics
- Physics curriculum
- Physics Kits
- Poetry
- Poetry
- Political Geography
- Portuguese
- Pre-Algebra
- Public Speaking
- Pumpkin Seed Press
- Quality Science
- Quitting Church
- Read Right
- Reading
- Reading comprehension
- Reading for young children
- Reading foreign language
- Reading Games
- Reading Program
- Reading Review
- Reading Specialist
- Reading Success
- Reading Tools
- Readorium
- Recent brain research
- remedial math program
- Remedial Reading
- Review
- Review by Emerson Sandow
- Review by Jennifer Nairne
- review by Joseph Grayhaim
- Review by Michael Leppert
- review by Valerie Schuetta
- review of Create-a-Story
- Review of creative writing program
- review of Mountain Math
- review of Music-Theory Online
- review of School Made Simple
- Rick Fisher
- Right Start Math
- Russia
- Russian
- Sample Kit
- Sarasota Art Schools
- SAT
- SAT Prep
- SAT score improvement
- Saxophone Lessons
- School Made Simple
- Science & Math
- Science and Math
- Science curriculum
- Science drawing
- Science for children
- Science for Christian Students
- Science Kits
- Science products
- Science Review
- Scientific concepts
- scientific content
- Scientific Illustration
- Scientists
- Scottsdale
- Secular Homeschooling
- See-n-Read
- See-n-Spell™
- Self-confidence
- Self-discipline
- Sequential learning
- Shakespeare's Plays
- Sign Language
- Sir Francis Bacon
- soft plush world globe
- songs that teach
- Space travel
- Spanish
- Spanish
- Spanish English elementary fiction
- Spanish English storybook
- Spanish for kids
- Spanish Vocabulary
- Special Ed
- Special Ed
- Special Ed Math
- Speech Pathologist
- Spelling
- Spelling
- Spelling Aid
- Spelling games
- STEM
- Stop Bullying
- Story elements
- String players resources
- Study Habits
- Success
- Sujoy Strings
- SumBlox
- synapses
- Tactile Learners
- Teacher Resources
- team building
- team work
- Test Prep
- The Arts
- The Homeschool Review
- Theatre Arts
- Tuxedo Publishing
- Typing
- Uncategorized
- United States history
- University of Denver
- Unlock Math
- Up-Words
- Valerie Schuetta
- Video games that teach
- Video learning
- Viola resources
- Violinist resources
- Visual Learning
- Vocabulary and Spelling Quick Reference Guide
- Vocabulary board games
- Vocabulary Development
- Voice lessons
- Wanda C Phillips
- Watercolor lessons
- We R Fun Games
- William Shakespeare
- word games
- World Affairs
- world geography
- World Government
- World History
- World Peace
- Write At Home
- Writing curriculum
- Writing games
- www.californiahomeschoolingtoday.com
- www.churchathome.org
- www.classroomreviewsnow.com
- www.collegetranscriptsnow.com
- www.conceptuallearning.com
- www.createpress.com
- www.easygrammar.com
- www.highschoolmathonline.com
- www.homeschoolmagazine.com
- www.homeschoolnewslink.com
- www.peacetoys.com
- www.schoolmadesimple.com
- www.sumblox.com
- www.talkingfingers.com
- www.tutoringforreading.com
- Young child literacy